Jewish people: Is it true that the stories of the book don’t matter?

… and that there is a hidden message or meaning?

Jews can study the text of the Torah on four levels:

* Peshat, the plain (simple) or literal reading;
* Remez, the allegorical reading through text’s hint or allusion
* Derash, the metaphorical reading through a (rabbinic sermon’s) comparison/illustration (midrash)
* Sod, the hidden meaning reading through text’s secret or mystery

One level of meaning doesn’t negate any other.
The "stories" matter, however you choose to interpret them.

7 Responses to “Jewish people: Is it true that the stories of the book don’t matter?”

  1. Panther says:

    to what book are you referring ?
    References :

  2. Fireball says:

    THE BIBLE MATTERS..
    References :

  3. Gorgeoustx Please send rain! says:

    Yes, the Jews consider most of the bible to be allegory.
    References :

  4. NewlyBorn says:

    I never address the Jews because they are not religious people. They only defend their Judaic roots. The ultra conservative Jews will never show up in here! I may be wrong… but that only in somebody’s perception…
    References :

  5. Gate Guardian Ruth says:

    answer: Some Jews view the first part of Genesis as a teaching myth and doubt that a global flood occurred. Some Jews view the first part of Genesis as a teaching myth but all other stories as actual. Some Jews view most of the stories in the Tanakh as legends/teaching tales. Some Jews believe everything, especially in the Torah, as factual.

    NB is having a fit of wishful thinking, probably because Jews won’t convert. I know MANY Jews who are very religious (including myself as someone converting).
    References :

  6. Yael says:

    Of course the stories in the Torah (AKA Bible) matter. They are fact.

    What you are referring to is called Midrash. In a nutshell- Midrash is the "expanded version" of what actually occured. While the Torah might reference an incident in just a few words, the Midrash expands on what happened, going into much more detail.
    Sometimes, the Midrash will take a story out of context to portray a "hidden meaning" but that doesn’t mean that the actual story never occured.
    References :
    Orthodox Jew, studied Torah and Midrash

  7. SheyneinNH says:

    Jews can study the text of the Torah on four levels:

    * Peshat, the plain (simple) or literal reading;
    * Remez, the allegorical reading through text’s hint or allusion
    * Derash, the metaphorical reading through a (rabbinic sermon’s) comparison/illustration (midrash)
    * Sod, the hidden meaning reading through text’s secret or mystery

    One level of meaning doesn’t negate any other.
    The "stories" matter, however you choose to interpret them.
    References :
    Me, Conservative Jew and former Hebrew School teacher

Leave a Reply